Julie Young

A tiny black pollywog named Finn wishes he were a boy. His brothers and sisters laugh at him. When Finn spots a fishing hook bobbing in the water, he sees this as an opportunity to join the human world. He is reeled in by a little boy named Colten, who has plans to fry the little pollywog. Colten’s Papa suggests he takes the pollywog home to see if it grows into a frog. Colten puts the pollywog into a goldfish bowl, and watches it grow and change. But as Finn begins to look more frog-like, he becomes sad. He isn’t sad because he doesn’t look like a boy, he is sad because he misses his family. Colten notices the pollywog is sad and he returns him back to the pond. Colten misses the pollywog, but Finn is happy to be back home where he belongs.

Be Careful What You Wish For is a sweet and charming children’s picture book about a little pollywog who has big dreams. Dissatisfied with his life in a pond, he manages to escape but soon discovers that life isn’t any better outside of the pond after all. Instead of becoming a boy, he is trapped in a goldfish bowl, lonely and confused, slowly turning into a frog. The book explores themes of identity, family and self-acceptance through the eyes of a tiny pond creature. Julie Young’s storytelling is gentle and warm, and the expressive illustrations guide young readers through the little pollywogs emotional journey of self-discovery. The book is filled with humor and heart, and the message is quietly powerful.

Star rating: 5 Stars 

Summary: A captivating picture book about an adventurous pollywog with big dreams.